Our Favorite Kerikeri Restaurants (Bay of Islands, New Zealand)

(December 6, 2012 – March 5, 2013)

There are many eateries in Kerikeri, and we certainly didn’t get to all of them.  But we did have some favorites that I’d love to mention here, not just for anyone interested back in the US but for our fellow cruisers here in New Zealand.  (It’s late in the season as I write this, but there are quite a few of us coming back next year).  I will start with our four favorite places in Kerikeri (in no particular order) and one honorable mention.

Cafe Jerusalem

We heard great things about this place, and we weren’t disappointed.  The food is Middle Eastern and is amazing; plus there’s a beautiful vine-covered patio where you can sit and enjoy your meal . I can’t say enough about this place.  If you find yourself in Kerikeri, make it a point to check it out!

Inside Cafe Jerusalem
Inside Cafe Jerusalem
The vine-covered patio outside Cafe Jerusalem was a beautiful place to enjoy the food.
The vine-covered patio outside Cafe Jerusalem was a beautiful place to enjoy the food.
The Shakshuka at Cafe Jerusalem
The Shakshuka at Cafe Jerusalem

Aegean Pizzeria

This place is just off the main street and is easy to overlook.  I was skeptical when we first went as they advertise kebabs, souvlaki, pizza and pasta, which seems like a strange combination of specialties to me.  But then we had the Aegean Special pizza, one of the best things I’ve ever eaten in my life!  We came back regularly and found the kebabs and souvlaki are also delicious (we never tried the pasta as that pizza was just too good to bypass again).  The coffee drinks are great, as are the desserts—I especially recommend the Chocolate Marquise.  This place is a gem!

Update: Last we were in Kerikeri, this place, sadly, had closed.

The Aegean Special, an amazing pizza. (Notice it's half gone before we get around to taking the picture!)
The Aegean Special, an amazing pizza. (Notice it’s half gone before we get around to taking the picture!)

The Italians

This place is very special, and would be just as special in New York or Los Angeles as it is in Kerikeri.  The chef/owner is Northern Italian and cooks the dishes of that region.  The Italians is only open for dinner and can be pricey, but they have a pasta special on Thursday nights where you can get a pasta dish, bread, and a glass of wine for $25 NZD. For food of this caliber, it is a great bargain.  Be warned: the food can take some time to get to your table, but it’s worth the wait.  This place is not just something to seek out in Kerikeri, it is a reason to visit Kerikeri.

Update: The Italians has since lost their lease in Kerikeri and closed, but we’ve heard (but not confirmed) that they’ve re-opened their restaurant in Paihia.

The Italians from the outside, small and simple.
The Italians from the outside, small and simple.
Rich enjoying an amazing pasta dinner.
Rich enjoying an amazing pasta dinner.

The Pear Tree Bar and Restaurant

The food is really good, and the setting down by the river basin is spectacular.  It can be pricey, but it’s wonderful for a special lunch or dinner out.  We came here for lunch one day with some friends, and promptly made reservations for our Valentine’s Day dinner.  It was perfect.

This was a wonderful place to go for a Valentine’s Day dinner.
This was a wonderful place to go for a Valentine’s Day dinner.
The gorgeous view from The Pear Tree.
The gorgeous view from The Pear Tree.
The path along the river behind the Pear Tree.
The path along the river behind the Pear Tree.

And the Honorable Mention:

Food at Wharepuke (yep, that’s the name of the restaurant)

The food is very good and the place is beautiful; so I’m not sure why this wasn’t a favorite. I guess it’s that the prices are a little high and the portions are a little small.  That said, it’s worth going at least once to just enjoy the beautiful deck.  Just don’t go with a big appetite, or swing by the McDonald’s up the street after you go.  (I do hear they have a wonderful Thai buffet dinner on the weekend.) –Cyndi

The beautiful deck outside Food at Wharepuke.
The beautiful deck outside Food at Wharepuke.
Even the parking lot at Food is beautiful.
Even the parking lot at Food is beautiful.
Liked it? Take a second to support TwoAtSea on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!